The enhanced premium tax credits that millions of American families relied on through the marketplace expired at the end of 2025 — and for families who had quietly built their budgets around that help, the January renewal letters hit like a gut punch. According to HealthCare.gov, the premium tax credit is still available in 2026, but the enhanced subsidy structure that capped premiums at 8.5% of household income for all income levels is no longer in effect. For families hovering in the upper-middle income range, the math changed fast.
I crossed paths with Brittany Jennings in February 2026, near the pharmacy section of a Giant Eagle in Cleveland’s West Side. She was staring at her phone with the kind of focused frustration that I recognized immediately — the look of someone running numbers that refuse to cooperate. I introduced myself, mentioned I write about personal finance, and she let out a short, exhausted laugh. “You picked the right person,” she said. Two weeks later, we sat down at a coffee shop near her home in Parma, and she walked me through a year that had not gone the way she planned.
The Raise That Changed Everything
Brittany Jennings is 50 years old, a retail store manager with a regional chain, and the kind of person who describes herself as “a spreadsheet person” before admitting that the spreadsheets failed her this time. She lives in a four-bedroom house in Parma with her husband Marcus, an HVAC technician, and three kids — Jade, 16, Caleb, 12, and Lily, 8 — split between their two families from prior marriages.
In October 2024, Brittany was promoted from floor manager to store manager at her location. Her annual salary climbed from $71,200 to $88,400. Combined with Marcus’s income of roughly $58,000, the household was now pulling in approximately $146,400 a year. That felt, as she put it, like real breathing room after years of careful budgeting on tighter margins.
The lifestyle adjustments came quickly — and, Brittany acknowledged, not always thoughtfully. The family signed Lily up for competitive gymnastics at $310 a month. Caleb started club soccer. Brittany and Marcus replaced their 2015 Honda Pilot with a 2023 model, adding a $521 monthly car payment. They also began ordering dinner out two or three nights a week instead of one. “None of it was extravagant,” she told me. “Every single thing felt totally reasonable at the time.”
When the Insurance Bill Arrived
Through 2025, the Jennings family was enrolled in a silver-tier ACA marketplace plan in Ohio, covering all five members. With the enhanced premium tax credits in place, their monthly premium came to $412. It wasn’t cheap, but Brittany had budgeted around it for two years and treated it as a stable line item.
Then, in late November 2025, the open enrollment renewal paperwork arrived. Their 2026 premium — for the same plan, same family — was listed at $847 per month. Brittany said she read the number three times. “I thought there was a typo. I genuinely could not process it.”
The reason was layered. The enhanced subsidies that had been in place since 2021 under the American Rescue Plan — and extended through the Inflation Reduction Act — expired at the end of 2025 without a congressional extension. At the Jennings family’s income level, that shift materially reduced the tax credit they received. As KFF’s analysis of the subsidy expiration showed, middle-to-upper-middle income families faced some of the sharpest percentage increases in net premiums once enhanced credits disappeared.
Counting the Real Cost of Lifestyle Inflation
What made Brittany’s situation particularly difficult was the timing. By the time the renewal letter arrived, the family’s monthly expenses had already ballooned alongside the raise. She pulled up a rough budget breakdown when we met and walked me through it.
Brittany’s net take-home increase from the promotion was roughly $1,100 per month after taxes — a number she hadn’t calculated precisely until I asked her to during our conversation. She went quiet for a moment when she realized the lifestyle additions had outpaced the raise by more than $600 a month even before accounting for the insurance jump. “I’m a manager,” she said. “I plan things for a living. And I completely missed this.”
Part of what drove the spending, she explained, was the blended family dynamic. The three kids each came with loyalties, schedules, and activities that Brittany and Marcus tried to accommodate equally. Pulling back on a commitment — like Caleb’s soccer or Lily’s gymnastics — felt to Brittany less like financial management and more like favoritism. “When you’ve got kids from two different households trying to feel like one family, you compensate,” she said. “I know that’s not rational. But it’s real.”
Where Brittany Stands Now
When we met in February, Brittany was two months into the new premium and already working through a reset. She and Marcus had sat down with a notepad — not a spreadsheet, she specified with some self-deprecating humor — and gone through every line item. The 2023 Pilot was not going to be returned, but the dining-out budget was cut from roughly $480 a month to $180. Lily’s gymnastics was under review for the spring session.
Brittany told me she had also looked into whether her employer’s group health plan was an option. She had previously declined it because the marketplace plan, with subsidies, was cheaper. That calculation has now flipped. She was waiting on updated plan documents from her HR department when we spoke and expected to make a decision before the next open enrollment window.
According to HealthCare.gov’s guidance on job-based coverage, employees who have access to employer-sponsored insurance that meets minimum value and affordability standards are generally not eligible for marketplace premium tax credits — something Brittany said she hadn’t fully understood when she made her original enrollment decision two years earlier.
The outcome so far is mixed. Brittany and Marcus are not in financial crisis — her income and their combined stability give them room to course-correct. But the gap between where she thought the promotion would put her family and where they actually landed is real, and she is still closing it. She described the experience not as a disaster but as a sharp, unwelcome lesson about how quickly the assumptions underneath a budget can quietly shift.
When I left the coffee shop, she was already on her phone — checking the HR portal, she said, for the employer plan documents. The spreadsheet person, it turns out, had just been working from the wrong spreadsheet.
Related: Her Health Insurance Bill Doubled to $558 a Month — Then a Portland Woman Found a Government Credit She Had Been Leaving on the Table
Related: He Got a Raise, Spent More, Lost His Overtime — Then Came a $3,800 IRS Bill
Leave a Reply