My Divorce Left Me $22K in Debt and Paying $1,600 a Month — Three Years Later, I Still Can’t Save a Dime

Most people think divorce is the hard part. The paperwork, the lawyers, the custody hearings — they imagine that once the judge signs the decree,…

My Divorce Left Me $22K in Debt and Paying $1,600 a Month — Three Years Later, I Still Can't Save a Dime
My Divorce Left Me $22K in Debt and Paying $1,600 a Month — Three Years Later, I Still Can't Save a Dime

Most people think divorce is the hard part. The paperwork, the lawyers, the custody hearings — they imagine that once the judge signs the decree, the worst is over. Tommy Bianchi, a 46-year-old HVAC technician from Phoenix, Arizona, would tell you that is exactly backwards. The hard part, he says, is every single month after.

I met Tommy at a diner off I-10 on a Tuesday morning in late March 2026. He was still in his work uniform — a blue collared shirt with a company logo on the chest — and he ordered coffee before he even sat down. He had the kind of tired that doesn’t come from a single bad night’s sleep.

The Divorce Settlement That Didn’t End at the Courthouse

Tommy’s marriage ended in 2022 after twelve years. He and his ex-wife had two kids, a house in the Ahwatukee Foothills neighborhood, and what he described as a comfortable, if stretched, life on his technician’s income. When the divorce was finalized, the house went to his ex-wife, and Tommy walked out carrying roughly $22,000 in attorney fees he had charged across three credit cards.

“I didn’t fight as hard as I maybe should have,” Tommy told me, wrapping both hands around his coffee mug. “My lawyer kept saying, just settle, it’ll cost more to fight. So I settled. And then I got the bill for settling.”

KEY TAKEAWAY
Tommy Bianchi left his divorce with $22,000 in credit card debt from legal fees, no home equity, and a court-ordered child support obligation of $1,600 per month — roughly 25% of his gross monthly income.

The child support order came to $1,600 per month. Tommy earns approximately $6,400 per month gross as a senior HVAC technician — a solid wage by most measures. But according to Arizona state law, child support calculations are based on gross income, not take-home pay. That means a quarter of every dollar he earns before taxes is spoken for before he touches it.

After federal and state taxes, his credit card minimums, rent on a two-bedroom apartment in Mesa, and the child support, Tommy figures he has roughly $800 to $1,000 left each month for everything else — food, gas, utilities, and the weekends with his kids.

What ‘Every Other Weekend’ Actually Costs

Tommy has his two children — a son, 14, and a daughter, 11 — every other weekend. That’s four days per month. He described those days to me with a mix of joy and something that sounded like quiet shame.

“I want them to have fun when they’re with me. I want them to feel like their dad has it together. So I take them to Top Golf, we go to the movies, I buy them whatever they want at dinner. And then Monday comes and I look at my bank account and I want to throw up.”
— Tommy Bianchi, HVAC Technician, Phoenix AZ

He estimates he spends between $400 and $600 on those two weekends combined — a figure he knows is unsustainable and admits he cannot stop. Psychologists have a name for this pattern: “guilt spending,” the tendency of non-custodial parents to compensate for limited time with money. Tommy hasn’t seen a therapist, but he recognized the behavior when I described it to him.

“Yeah,” he said flatly. “That’s exactly what it is. I know it. Doesn’t stop me.”

$1,600
Monthly child support payment

$22,000
Legal fees on credit cards

$500
Avg. spent per visit weekend

Three Years of Renting and Going Nowhere

Tommy has been renting a two-bedroom apartment in Mesa since the divorce was finalized. The second bedroom is for the kids. He pays $1,450 per month — a price that felt manageable in 2022 and has since been raised twice by his landlord, most recently to $1,580 in January 2026.

He wants to buy a house. He talks about it the way people talk about a trip they keep planning and never taking. The math, as he laid it out for me, is brutal.

Monthly Expense Amount Notes
Child Support $1,600 Court-ordered, 25% of gross
Rent $1,580 Raised twice since 2022
Credit Card Minimums ~$480 Three cards, ~$22K balance
Weekend Spending (Kids) ~$500 Avg. across two weekends/month
Gas, Food, Utilities ~$700 Estimate
Remaining (Net) ~$0–$200 Before any emergency

“I’ve got maybe two hundred bucks left at the end of the month if nothing goes wrong,” Tommy said. “And something always goes wrong. Last month my truck needed brakes. That was $380. So I put it on a card.” He gestured at the phone in his pocket as if the credit card was living there, waiting.

A conventional mortgage on a modest Phoenix-area home — say, a $280,000 property — would require a down payment of roughly $9,800 at 3.5% under an FHA loan, according to HUD guidelines. Tommy has saved approximately $1,200 toward that goal over three years. At his current rate, he estimates it would take him another six to eight years to reach the threshold — assuming nothing else breaks.

⚠ IMPORTANT
Child support obligations in Arizona are calculated on gross income, not net. This means Tommy’s $1,600 monthly obligation is drawn from earnings before taxes are withheld — leaving his actual take-home pay significantly lower than the gross figure used in the court calculation. Non-custodial parents facing similar situations may qualify for a modification review if their financial circumstances change substantially, according to the Arizona Department of Economic Security.

The Bitterness He’s Trying Not to Pass On

Tommy is not a man who hides his feelings well, but he is clearly trying. He mentioned his ex-wife three times during our conversation and caught himself each time, redirecting. “I’m not going to do that,” he said once, mid-sentence, and changed the subject. It was one of the more quietly dignified things I’ve seen in an interview.

He is bitter about the settlement. He believes he paid more in legal fees than he should have, that he was counseled to concede too much, and that the house — which has appreciated significantly in the Phoenix market since 2022 — would have given him equity he desperately needs now. He may be right. He may also be filtering the past through three years of financial strain. Probably both.

“I don’t want my kids to know how stressed I am about money. They’re kids. That’s not their problem. So I smile and I take them to dinner and I worry about it Sunday night after I drop them off.”
— Tommy Bianchi

What struck me most was how clearly Tommy understood his own situation and how little that understanding had changed it. He knows the weekend spending is a problem. He knows paying minimums on $22,000 in credit card debt at interest rates between 22% and 26% APR is a losing battle. He knows that saving $200 a month — on a good month — will not get him into a house before his kids graduate high school.

Knowing and changing are different things, and Tommy is stuck somewhere in the space between them.

Where He Stands Now — and What He’s Hoping For

Tommy told me he recently looked into whether his child support order could be modified. His income has stayed roughly flat over the past two years — he got a small raise in 2024, about $1.50 an hour — but he hasn’t pursued a formal review. “I looked it up online,” he said. “It seemed like a lot of paperwork and I’d probably need a lawyer again. I can’t afford another lawyer.”

Where Tommy’s Money Goes Each Month
1
Child Support — $1,600 — Court-ordered, paid directly to ex-wife, 25% of gross income

2
Rent — $1,580 — Two-bedroom in Mesa, raised twice since divorce

3
Credit Card Minimums — ~$480 — Three cards carrying divorce legal fees, 22–26% APR

4
Weekend Spending — ~$500 — Guilt-driven spending during custody visits; Tommy calls this his biggest regret

He has not applied for any assistance programs. He earns too much to qualify for SNAP benefits — the federal income threshold for a household of one is roughly $2,311 per month net, according to USDA Food and Nutrition Service, and Tommy’s net income, while tight, exceeds that. He has employer-sponsored health insurance through his HVAC company, which he described as “decent but not great.”

His retirement savings are minimal. He contributes 3% to a 401(k) to capture his employer’s match — “I’m not giving up free money,” he said, and that line was the most financially clear-eyed thing he said all morning — but he hasn’t increased contributions since the divorce.

“I’m 46. I should have equity in a house by now. I should have more in savings. I look at guys I went to high school with and I think, how did they get so far ahead? And then I remember — they didn’t get divorced.”
— Tommy Bianchi, age 46

When I asked him what he wanted people to take away from his story, Tommy was quiet for a moment. He looked out the window at the parking lot. “I just want people to know it doesn’t go away fast,” he said. “The divorce is over but the divorce isn’t over. You know what I mean?”

I did know what he meant. And three years in, with $1,200 saved toward a down payment and $22,000 still on credit cards, Tommy Bianchi is living proof that the financial aftermath of a marriage can outlast the marriage itself by a very long time.

He finished his coffee, left a cash tip on the table, and went back to work.

Related: She Earns Union Wages and Still Can’t Retire — The Hidden Cost of Family Caregiving on Social Security

Related: She Earns a Union Salary and Still Can’t Save for Retirement — What Caregiving Really Costs in America

Frequently Asked Questions

How is child support calculated in Arizona?

In Arizona, child support is calculated based on gross income — earnings before taxes — not take-home pay. The state uses an income shares model, meaning both parents’ incomes are considered. Tommy Bianchi’s $1,600 monthly obligation represents approximately 25% of his gross monthly income of $6,400. More details are available through the Arizona Department of Economic Security at des.az.gov.
Can child support be modified after a divorce is finalized in Arizona?

Yes. In Arizona, either parent can request a child support modification if there has been a substantial and continuing change in circumstances — typically a change in income of 15% or more. The request must be filed with the court, and a new calculation is performed. Tommy Bianchi mentioned he looked into this but was deterred by the paperwork and the cost of hiring another attorney.
Do divorce legal fees qualify for any tax deductions?

As of current IRS rules, personal legal fees related to divorce — including attorney fees for custody or property settlements — are generally not tax-deductible for federal purposes. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 eliminated the miscellaneous itemized deduction that once allowed some legal fee deductions. Tommy’s $22,000 in attorney fees charged to credit cards would not reduce his federal tax liability.
What is the income limit to qualify for SNAP benefits as a single adult?

For fiscal year 2025-2026, the USDA sets the gross monthly income limit for SNAP eligibility at 130% of the federal poverty level. For a household of one, that is approximately $1,632 gross per month. Tommy Bianchi’s income exceeds these thresholds, making him ineligible for SNAP assistance, according to the USDA Food and Nutrition Service.
What is the minimum down payment for an FHA loan on a home?

FHA loans require a minimum down payment of 3.5% for borrowers with a credit score of 580 or higher, according to HUD guidelines. On a $280,000 home, that would be $9,800. Tommy has saved approximately $1,200 toward a down payment over three years of renting in Mesa, Arizona.

218 articles

Sloane Avery Wren

Senior Benefits Writer covering Social Security, Medicare, and retirement policy. M.P.P. University of Michigan. Former CBPP researcher. NSSA Certified.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *